.png)
Key Takeaways
- Compare channels by the revenue your portfolio retains after commissions, refunds, payment processing, and acquisition costs.
- Reservation and revenue shares reveal different booking patterns, but neither alone establishes which channel delivers stronger net returns.
- Benchmark your channel mix against similar properties in your local market, using national figures for broader context.
Short-term rental platforms are websites and apps, such as Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com, where guests find and book vacation rental properties.
Your company may already use several of these platforms alongside a direct booking website. The key question is whether that mix reflects a deliberate strategy or a habit, and how it compares with similar properties in your market.
What Are the Main Short-Term Rental Platforms Property Managers Use?
Property management companies typically distribute listings across four booking channels: Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, and a direct booking website. The main channels to evaluate include:
- Airbnb: Provides access to a broad vacation rental audience, with professional tools including a multi-calendar and listing performance reports for managing multiple properties.
- Vrbo: Its distribution network can give eligible listings exposure on additional sites, including Expedia and Travelocity. The distribution is subject to eligibility and is not guaranteed.
- Booking.com: Places vacation rentals alongside hotels and apartments, giving property managers access to travelers searching across different accommodation types.
- Direct booking website: Gives your company its own space to present the portfolio, accept reservations, and collect visitor and booking data.
Niche, regional, and mid-term rental platforms are additional options to consider where their audiences and stay requirements fit the properties you manage.
How Do Platform Fees and Net Revenue Compare?
For this analysis, net channel revenue means booking revenue after refunds, platform commissions, payment processing, and attributable marketing costs. Use the same cost categories across channels so the comparison is consistent. This is not the same as company profit, which also depends on owner agreements and other operating expenses.
Note: Platform fee structures change frequently. The figures below are current as of October 2026, but property managers should confirm current fees and any account-specific terms directly with each platform.
Airbnb: Airbnb’s single-fee model applies to most software-connected listings, with most accounts paying 15.5%. Confirm any exceptions in your account’s fee breakdown.
Vrbo: Vrbo has announced a new 12% commission structure beginning October 29, 2026. Because the change has not yet taken effect, property managers should confirm how the new structure will apply to their account and software setup before using the 12% rate in channel comparisons.
Booking.com: Booking.com charges commission on bookings, with the percentage shown at the Agreement step during registration. Booking.com does not charge commission when a guest cancels without a cancellation fee. If the guest pays a cancellation fee, commission may apply to the amount collected.
Direct booking website: A direct booking website avoids OTA commission, while your company covers its own acquisition and transaction costs. When assessing the channel's contribution, include payment processing, website or booking-engine charges, and attributable marketing spend.
Comparing retained revenue alongside booking volume, length of stay, and acquisition costs gives you a more complete view of each channel’s contribution to the portfolio. Use those results to assess whether each channel’s bookings justify its costs as part of your revenue management strategy.
What Does Booking Data Say About Channel Mix?
According to KeyData’s U.S. Summer Index release, Airbnb accounted for 51% of reservations and 43% of revenue in its finalized Q2 2026 U.S. dataset, covering April–June. Those shares increased from 47% and 36%, respectively, in Q2 2025. The index uses anonymized, actual reservations supplied through integrated property management systems.
In the same Q2 2026 comparison, direct bookings represented 21% of reservations and 29% of revenue, down from 25% and 36% in Q2 2025. Vrbo remained unchanged year over year at 20% of reservations and 23% of revenue.
Direct bookings contributed a larger share of revenue than reservations, while Airbnb did the opposite. Revenue per reservation can reflect stay length, property mix, and nightly rates, so this pattern alone doesn’t prove that one channel performs better or delivers stronger net returns.
Your portfolio’s booking mix may differ from the U.S. figures depending on the markets and property types you manage. Use the national data for context, then compare your short-term rental performance with similar properties in your market.
How Do You Build a Channel Mix That Fits Your Portfolio?
Work through these five steps for each market or property group your company manages:
- Audit your current channel mix.
Use reservation counts and revenue by booking source for the same completed stay period. Calculate each channel’s share of reservations and revenue, keeping direct bookings separate from third-party platforms. - Compare what you retain.
Look at net revenue across channels using consistent cost categories. Compare total retained revenue and retained revenue per booked night so differences in booking volume and length of stay don’t distort the picture. - Compare your mix with the market.
Benchmark channel shares against similar properties in your local market, aligning factors such as property type, bedroom count, and stay dates. ProData can help identify differences between your portfolio and the broader market, but those benchmarks should provide context rather than targets to match. - Define what makes sense for your portfolio.
Define what a healthy channel mix looks like for each market or property tier based on costs, booking patterns, operating capacity, and business goals. - Track how the mix changes.
Review channel performance against the same period a year earlier, accounting for changes in inventory, holiday timing, major events, and distribution strategy. Look across several comparable periods before treating a shift as a sustained trend.
Before adding another platform, confirm that your systems can track its bookings, revenue, and costs separately. A single quarter’s shift warrants investigation; look across several comparable periods before treating it as a sustained trend.
Make Your Channel Mix a Decision, Not a Habit
A deliberate channel mix starts with understanding what each booking source contributes, what it costs to acquire that business, and how your portfolio compares with similar properties in the market.
Channel share will change as traveler behavior, platform fees, inventory, and market conditions change. Reviewing those shifts over time can help your team decide whether your current distribution strategy is still working for the portfolio.
For a broader U.S. comparison, request the latest index and review quarterly channel mix trends alongside your own results.
Book a demo to explore your channel mix and compare it with market benchmarks.
FAQ
What are the main short-term rental booking platforms?
Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com are among the major third-party platforms used by professional property managers. Many operators also generate reservations through their own direct booking websites and may use niche or regional platforms depending on their markets.
How should property managers compare short-term rental platforms?
Look beyond reservation volume and platform commission. Compare revenue, booking volume, length of stay, cancellations, payment processing, marketing costs, and other attributable expenses to understand what each channel contributes to the portfolio.
What is a channel mix in vacation rentals?
A channel mix is the combination of booking sources that generate reservations for a property or portfolio, including third-party platforms such as Airbnb and Vrbo and a company’s direct booking channel.
Is direct booking always more profitable than an OTA?
Not necessarily. Direct bookings avoid OTA commissions but still have costs associated with payment processing, website technology, marketing, and guest acquisition. Comparing consistent cost categories across channels provides a better view of their relative contribution.
